How to Hire a Trustworthy Independent Private Caregiver

Hiring a caregiver comes down to one question: Can you trust this person with your parents?

It’s not an easy one to answer. A clean background check confirms there’s no record of past problems, but it doesn't tell you how someone will act on a hard day, alone in your parent's home, when no one else is watching. Most families who've been through this will tell you the same thing: you can lower the risk substantially by doing your homework up front, like checking references, verifying a background, and starting with a paid trial run.

This guide is about lowering that risk enough that you can feel good about who's walking through your parent's door, whether you're figuring that out alone or with a sibling.

Short on time? Skip ahead to the "How to vet a caregiver" section.

If you have more runway, the fuller process below is worth the time.

What hiring a private caregiver actually means

Families choose to hire directly instead of going through an agency for a lot of reasons: more control over who's actually in the home, real cost savings, and the chance to build a relationship with one consistent caregiver instead of rotating staff. 

When you hire a caregiver directly instead of through an agency, you generally become their household employer — a status based on the control you have over the work, not on how much you pay them. Where wages come in is tax withholding: For 2026, you're responsible for withholding Social Security and Medicare taxes once you pay a caregiver $3,000 or more in cash wages during the year, and federal unemployment tax rules apply once you pay $1,000 or more in any single calendar quarter. As a direct employer, you're generally responsible for things an agency would otherwise handle. That includes paying at least minimum wage and overtime, where required, withholding and paying employment taxes, and in some states, carrying workers' compensation coverage. None of this needs to be intimidating, and we'll walk through the payroll side further down. 

Where to find a private caregiver

Most families don't land on a caregiver through a single obvious channel. It's usually a mix, and where someone comes from tells you about how much vetting you'll still need to do yourself. A referral from someone who already trusts the person is a different starting point than a profile on an open registry, even if both can lead to a good hire.

• Word of mouth. A recommendation from someone who's actually worked with the caregiver is one of the strongest signals of trust you'll find.
• Community groups. Local Facebook groups (searching something like "caregiver support in [your city]"), nextdoor or your city or region’s subreddit are often where the most trusted leads come from, because someone else has already vouched for the person.
• Care advisors. Independent advisors who specialize in matching families with caregivers can be worth the fee, especially if you're short on time or navigating a specific diagnosis.
• Hospital discharge planners and social workers. If your parent is coming home after a hospital stay, the discharge team often has a list of caregivers they've worked with before.
• Senior centers. Local senior centers frequently keep informal referral lists and can be a good starting point even if you're not sure what you need yet.
• Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) and nursing school career offices. Some students and recent graduates look for private caregiving work directly, and school career offices can connect you.
• Online caregiver registries. Care.com-style platforms are useful for volume, but it's worth knowing upfront that anyone can create a profile. The vetting responsibility sits with you.
• Nextdoor. A neighborhood-based app where people post local recommendations and alerts. Similar to Facebook groups: useful for hyper-local recommendations. A recommendation is a starting point and not a substitute for your own vetting.

If they're coming from an agency, know this first

If the caregiver you're considering currently works for or recently left an agency, here’s what families often miss:

1. Ask if they signed a non-compete or placement agreement. Some agencies build this into their contracts.

2. Treat a "yes" as a possible dealbreaker. Some agreements bar the caregiver from working with you directly for a set period.

3. If you're both still willing to move forward, expect a fee. Agencies can charge a buyout or placement fee to release a caregiver, and the amount isn't standardized, it's set by the individual agency's contract. Ask what that number would be before you commit to hiring them.

It's normal to still feel a low hum of worry even after someone checks every box. That's the honest cost of trusting a stranger with someone you love, and these steps are about lowering that worry.

If you're the one doing this research and a sibling or your parent will be the actual employer of record, loop them in on each step as you go rather than presenting a finished decision. Trust in the caregiver matters, and so does trust between the people making the call.

1. Background checks. Run one through a reputable screening service such as Checkr, GoodHire, or Sterling. It confirms there's no record of past problems, but remember that a clean check doesn't tell you whether someone has patience, or how they'll handle a hard day. A thorough check usually layers a few things: a national criminal database search, county-level court records (national databases can miss these), a sex offender registry check, and a driving record if the role involves transportation. 

▶️ Our complete guide to background checks walks through what each layer actually covers.

2. References, and how you check them. Ask for at least two, and actually call them. Ask what a hard day looked like, not just a good one. Ask whether they'd hire this person again.

3. A paid trial shift. Before committing to a schedule, pay for a few hours where you or a sibling are still around. This tells you more than an interview ever will: how they talk to your parent, how they handle a task that doesn't go as planned, whether the fit feels right.

4. Matching experience to the actual need. Companionship care, dementia care, and medical care call for different skill sets. Someone wonderful at keeping your parent company on a walk may not have the training to safely manage dementia-related behavior. That's a mismatch worth catching early. If any part of the role involves medications, be precise in the interview about what you actually need. Reminding someone to take a pill is different from administering medication, and the distinction matters for safety and, depending on your state, licensing.

▶️ Also read: The Complete Guide on How to Hire a Private In-Home Caregiver for an Elderly Parent

Paying a private caregiver the right way, without the headache

Once you've found the right person, the next question is usually some version of "do I really have to do all the tax stuff?"

The answer is yes, if you want to do it legally. Many families overestimate how complicated that actually is. In broad terms, paying "on the books" means registering as a household employer, withholding the right taxes from each paycheck, and filing on a regular schedule using IRS Schedule H. 

Workers' compensation requirements also vary by state and are worth checking early, since some states require it for household employers.

Note: Cost varies by state and policy, so check with your state's requirements or a payroll provider for current numbers.

If the idea of managing this yourself feels like one more thing on an already full plate, that's the gap a service like Poppins is built to close (currently $49/month, plus $10/month per additional employee). We help manage the registration, the withholding, and eligible federal and state tax filings, so you're not learning tax law in the middle of everything else you're managing for your parent.

Your backup plan: What happens when your caregiver calls out sick 

The question families ask least often, and regret not asking soonest, is what happens the day your caregiver can't work, whether that's a sudden illness or leaving the role altogether.

It's worth building the answer in from the start. A few practical approaches:

• Hire more than one caregiver from the beginning, splitting the week between them. It costs a bit more in coordination, but no single person's schedule becomes a single point of failure.
• Keep an agency on file for gap coverage. Even if you're not using one day-to-day, having a number to call for a one-off shift is worth the peace of mind.
• Talk about it in the interview and put it in the contract. Ask directly how much notice they'd try to give, and what they'd want you to do in an emergency. Naming the expectation early makes it far less awkward if it ever comes up.

This content is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Consult a qualified tax professional or attorney for guidance specific to your situation.

‍